PDA

View Full Version : Racket Testing !


DaveR
05-15-2008, 07:53 PM
http://www.sportfocus.com/newsimage/234587764_47d6f50177_o[1]19.jpg



Racket Testing will be taking place this weekend at the Cadet Masters aimed at education, awareness and data collection.

At the same time as this weekends event is taking place, the ETTA Chairman and Chief Executive will be meeting with members of the ITTF Executive Board, who are visiting London, to discuss a number of issues including Racket Testing.

Following these discussions in London, and through correspondence with the ITTF Equipment Committee, we will put in place a revised Racket Testing Procedure.

It is becoming apparent that some "boosters" can cause the rubbers to expand beyond the thickness limits approved in the regulations and that they can also cause an uneven surface.
Care should be taken in regard to this by the players as normal umpiring bat checks will be made.

It is also becoming clear that some “tuned” rubbers contain or react to water based glues causing over the limit VOC emissions. The ITTF are discussing these issues with the Manufacturers, who appear not to have been aware of this situation, and further information will follow".

This is an ETTA article but is worth following up on the "some tuned rubbers" are creating problems for the "sniffer" to the extent it seems many are failing and dont quote me on this but joola seems to be king of the failures in tuned rubbers so beware. There are various stories of players not glueing up for months and months but the joola tuned are still failing dismally, if this proves to be the case where does this leave us?

Do those who play with them stop doing so because of the problem or do they relax in favour because of it?

You can hardly blame those who are failing the test if its not their particular fault, which leads nicely into the question ........does this mean joola then "reimburce" or "replace" the rubber with another. Not going to happen i hear you say !

But will the problem be recified by changing the rubber / sponge design technology process.

This is exactly what many were saying before this came into play...........this is a complete mine field wating to explode, with players being reported or even a ban incurred if the rubber fails through no fault of their own.

Your thoughts are?

NativeNewYorker
05-15-2008, 08:05 PM
The rackets that failed in the juniors were joola it seems as i spoke to some upset parties, this is causing problems and will continue to do so unless the authorities come out and explain. My feeling is that they dont want to upset Joola yet or am i a cynic.

The Windmill
05-15-2008, 08:52 PM
I heard that there are only 2 testing machines in the UK at the present ? Does anyone know if this is true ?
If so the chances of being tested in local league are non existant !!!

Annie
05-15-2008, 09:21 PM
I heard that there are only 2 testing machines in the UK at the present ? Does anyone know if this is true ?
If so the chances of being tested in local league are non existant !!!

Gosh that's shocking if true! :Ahhh:

What a load of fuss and bother over nothing if that is the case.

I work for a small manufacturing company and have to implement changes and new systems/processes and the one thing I have learnt is if it isn't workable then think again! :popcorn:

Belisar
05-15-2008, 09:32 PM
I heard that there are only 2 testing machines in the UK at the present ? Does anyone know if this is true ?
If so the chances of being tested in local league are non existant !!!

Not sure how many testers there are in the UK but this was never going to be tested at local league level. Different matches on different evenings in different places, even if the league had the tester who would want to do the testing and how would they get to visit all of the teams ?

I feel sorry for all involved in a way. I understand the need to keep the game safe and therefore the need to rush in some equipment changes to remove VOC's. What I do not understand is if the "tuned" equipment actually contains VOC's or just acts as if it does as far as the sniffer is concerned (i.e. is the tester wrong or the rubber wrong).

I suspect that everyone is going to have to be flexible until all of the issues are discovered and ironed out. If we need to be flexible then it makes it very hard to weed out those who are innocent from those who are taking advantage.

I am disappointed if manufacturers have not been able to test their own equipment before release but suspect this was all a bit quick even for them.

Annie
05-15-2008, 09:45 PM
Look I'm no expert on equipment but what if everyone just played with wooden blades? As I have always maintained the most skillful player would always prevail wouldn't they?

Mr Wilko
05-22-2008, 10:04 PM
Look I'm no expert on equipment but what if everyone just played with wooden blades? As I have always maintained the most skillful player would always prevail wouldn't they?


erm in a word Annie .....................NO...................

JKC
05-22-2008, 10:37 PM
The most skillful player with a wooden bat would win that one. That is quite different to the most skillful player.